Mystery to Me

Hi there! 

Welcome to our Bookshop portal. If you're looking for our website, where you can see our store hours, place a special order, order a subscription package, and see what we currently have in stock, please click here! 

Mystery to Me may have a specific name, but we are a general-interest bookstore. We boast an extensive mystery selection, as well as lovingly curated fiction, non-fiction, classics, best-sellers, and children's books. We are located on Monroe Street, just a few blocks from the Badgers' Camp Randall Stadium. Many of our customers have asked how they can get the books they want, while doing it in a way that offers us the best support. Here are a few options:

(1) You can purchase books directly from us by searching our website to see what we have on our shelves. Our website is updated regularly with bookseller in-store hours and curbside pick-up times.

(2) You are welcome to call or email us with your questions or wishlists. We promise to get back to you as soon as we can.

(3) You can order on Bookshop! Our Bookshop lists are curated (and updated regularly) to include books we love, but may not currently have on our shelves at the store. We currently receive 25% of the sales made through our Bookshop portal (see the Mystery to Me logo on the top left corner). When you buy a book  through Bookshop, the book never comes to us on Monroe Street. It goes from a distribution center directly to you. 

Thanks for your support of independent bookstores! 

***