In the bustling town of Columbus, Ohio, in January 1927, Nathan Bolton grapples with societal expectations while navigating his career and personal relationships. When the strange behavior of his childhood friend, Dr. Henry Grindle, begins raising alarms, Nathan's life spirals into chaos after a series of murders linked to their circle of friends, including the mysterious Jacob Jagger and the tragic death of fellow student and performer, Lady Sapphire. As Nathan uncovers dark secrets and faces the consequences of loyalty and ambition, he must confront his past and the relationships that shape his future.