"Soffer provides an excellent summary of the history of the Office of Special Investigations, its establishment, and the obstacles that it faced to pursue the cases in the United States. Of particular interest are the author's descriptions of the OSI lawyers, such as Bruce Einhorn and Eli Rosenbaum, for whom the Kulle case was Rosenbaum's first at OSI, and later for many years became its director. Soffer also describes in great detail the local personalities on both sides of the debate about Kulle and how to decide his fate. What was of particular interest was the tireless efforts of some of the Jewish women residents of Oak Park who never gave up their pursuit to achieve justice despite the pressure they faced from their colleagues and neighbors. Leah Marcus, Rima Lunin Schultz, and Rae Lynne Toporoff helped make history, and they deserve the mention that Michael Soffer gave them."

-- "The Jerusalem Post"
"Soffer's book opens a window on a rarely investigated dynamic: What happens when "big history"--and it doesn't come any bigger than the Holocaust--collides with local community?"-- "Current Pub"
"... Soffer uncovers a fascinating local story with national implications for how we remember the past and deal with its painful resonances in the present."-- "Reader"

"[Soffer's] history book provides an exciting opportunity for readers to understand the depths of how impactful the event of the Holocaust was even after it was over."

-- "The Forest Scout"
"A carefully researched account. . . . The value of Soffer's book lies in its narrow focus on this situation and the effect it had on the people of a progressive American suburb."-- "Wall Street Journal"
"A pow­er­ful mix of schol­ar­ship and mem­oir; [Soffer's] research is metic­u­lous and his sto­ry­telling mat­ter-of-fact. . . . This book will linger for a long time in read­ers' minds."-- "Jewish Book Council"
"A Nazi prison camp guard hid in plain sight in America for nearly three decades after winning the trust of a suburban town whose residents adored him for his 'kind acts'. . . . But the revelation of his Nazi past nearly 30 years later split the town with many coming to his defense and saying he was the victim of a 'persecution'."-- "Daily Mail"
"How could a former Nazi come to the United States after the war and comfortably settle in Chicagoland? . . . [Soffer] being naturally inquisitive, incredibly smart, and someone looking to bring real world issues into his classroom wanted to dig deeper. . . . He discovered this story went far deeper than he could have imagined."-- "WGN Radio"
"It is an important important read, especially in our time of rising anti semitism in America and around the world. It tells, in very well researched prose and in beautiful writing, the story of what happened in Oak Park, Illinois when it was discovered that a long-time school custodian had in fact been a Nazi guard."-- "A Mighty Blaze"
"Reinhold Kulle and his family departed on the MS Italia from Cuxhaven, Germany, destined for a new life in America. But as [Soffer] reveals in Our Nazi, Kulle carried a dark secret. Throughout World War II, Kulle had not only been a member of the Nazi's Waffen-SS, but had worked at Gross-Rosen concentration camp where 40,000 Jews died."-- "New York Post"
"Our Nazi raises profound moral questions about justice, forgiveness, and Holocaust memory. Soffer deftly weaves together multiple story lines in this well-researched and riveting account."-- "Daniel Greene, Northwestern University"
"A chilling account of how someone with an evil past can hide in plain sight, and the lengths to which those who would expose him went to get a well-justified reckoning. Our Nazi reads like a novel, but is in fact a fine piece of scholarship that combines the history of the Holocaust, American policy, and life in suburbia in the postwar period."-- "Hasia Diner, emerita, New York University"
"An important work of history that is both deeply researched and beautifully written. Soffer illuminates an overlooked yet remarkable story of an American community's reckoning with justice in the wake of the Holocaust. He has achieved what the best history writers aim to do: shaping our view of the present by opening eyes to a new view of the past."-- "Jonathan Eig, author of King: A Life"