Happily in love, Bliss Taylor and Tamra Gray are absolutely certain that their boyfriends' hearts lie in the palms of their hands. Their friend Annie, however, begs to differ. Thus a wager is born, where hearts and pride are put on the line, and the games are officially begun.

Under the guise of a chat room welcoming incoming foreign exchange students, Bliss and Tamra don flirtatious and false identities in order to test their boyfriends' loyalties. With Bliss and Tamra out of town, the boys are left to their own devices. To their girlfriends' hearts will they remain true?